how to duplicate flowers in minecraft

News Rules Forum Chat Mods Maps Resource Packs Minecraft Station Desktop View
Home Minecraft Forum Minecraft: Java Edition Suggestions Farmable flowers! (Using bonemeal)
Search Search all Forums Search this Forum Search this Thread Tools Jump to Forum

Farmable flowers! (Using bonemeal)

Do you support this suggestion? – Single Choice

Yes 100% No (Please tell me why below) 0%
Void Walker Location: Minecraft Join Date: 1/19/2014 Posts: 1,659 Location: Earth Minecraft: The_8_Bit_Zombie Member Details
It”s a pretty straightforward suggestion. Right-clicking any flower with bonemeal spawns the item of that flower near it. This is already the case with double tall flowers, so why not normal ones?

Mark of the Beast Join Date: 3/25/2014 Posts: 928 Location: That's Classified Info Minecraft: WhiteleafYT Xbox: OutboardToaster PSN: Nada Member Details

Not only is this an infinity flower, but also there”s something called bonemeal on grass. Right click, and boom! You get flowers. With this method it is a cheap way of farming flowers, unless it takes like 5 pieces of bonemeal per, no support.

Đang xem: How to duplicate flowers in minecraft

My Channel: Whiteleaf

I am an artist. All the art you see on my profile is by me, if it”s not I will say so and whom its owner is.

I never even thought of this, and I will have to agree with Broccoli.

Flowers can already be obtained by bonemealing grass in the biome that your wanted flower spawns in, but since you already need one of the flowers, it only makes sense that you don”t have to walk back and forth just to bonemeal grass in order to get a purely decorative item.

The Meaning of Life, the Universe, and Everything. Location: Tochigi Join Date: 4/17/2015 Posts: 71 Location: Yaita Minecraft: Something 😀 Xbox: NA PSN: NA Member Details

I actually agree with Broccoli_Monkey, it makes to difference to gameplay really. It more like an aesthetics thing. It”d be great to actually finally be able to finish decorating my house.

Full Support.

Color does not define someone, their actions does.

Respect is like Trust, it has to be earned, not thrown right in your face just because.

Void Walker Location: Minecraft Join Date: 1/19/2014 Posts: 1,659 Location: Earth Minecraft: The_8_Bit_Zombie Member Details

You can only get all kinds of flowers by using bonemeal on grass in Flower forest biomes.
By the way, the OP is right. Doing this on a double tall flower (Rose bushes, lilacs, sunflowers, etc.) already works. And using bonemeal doesn”t need to be expensive on flowers. They”re only used as decoration, and to get specific kinds of dye. Who cares if you can farm them?
Full support.

I never even thought of this, and I will have to agree with Broccoli.

Flowers can already be obtained by bonemealing grass in the biome that your wanted flower spawns in, but since you already need one of the flowers, it only makes sense that you don”t have to walk back and forth just to bonemeal grass in order to get a purely decorative item.

Iron Miner Location: Toronto Join Date: 1/25/2015 Posts: 303 Minecraft: MartB77 Member Details

Simple, effective, and consistent with already existing behaviour.

Not having implemented this already is illogical.

Full support.

Mark of the Beast Join Date: 3/25/2014 Posts: 928 Location: That's Classified Info Minecraft: WhiteleafYT Xbox: OutboardToaster PSN: Nada Member Details

You can only get all kinds of flowers by using bonemeal on grass in Flower forest biomes.
By the way, the OP is right. Doing this on a double tall flower (Rose bushes, lilacs, sunflowers, etc.) already works. And using bonemeal doesn”t need to be expensive on flowers. They”re only used as decoration, and to get specific kinds of dye. Who cares if you can farm them?
Full support.

Read more: how to make a face in minecraft

Exactly, who cares if you farm them. But that”s my point, we already can make flower farms and flowers are easy to get. Skeleton grinder = bonemeal + flowers = more flowers. What”s the point of this is if you can already do what he”s suggesting? Plus this is literally duplicating items; and isn”t the way physics work in MC.

Still no support. Do not fix something if it”s not broken.

My Channel: Whiteleaf

I am an artist. All the art you see on my profile is by me, if it”s not I will say so and whom its owner is.

Mark of the Beast Join Date: 3/25/2014 Posts: 928 Location: That's Classified Info Minecraft: WhiteleafYT Xbox: OutboardToaster PSN: Nada Member Details

I repeat. You can NOT farm flowers using bone meal right now, unless you are in a flower forest biome. Adn even then, the flowers you”ll get are completely random. The system is broken as it is, as it is unreliable and you”ll need a rare (and possibly faraway) biome to do it in.

Actually, you can farm flowers with bonemeal WHEN you”re NOT in a flower forest biome. You just don”t get as many varieties; also, I don”t remember what video, but Ethoslab has a completely compatible with ANY flower flower farm.

I”m not going to argue anymore, do not fix what is not broken, no support. My final words for this thread.

My Channel: Whiteleaf

I am an artist. All the art you see on my profile is by me, if it”s not I will say so and whom its owner is.

Newbie Join Date: 12/21/2014 Posts: 4,035 Location: In your hair Minecraft: My_Unit Member Details

I, on the other hand agree with this.

Players seem perfectly fine with literally just about any other type of farm, what makes flowers an exception?

Mark of the Beast Join Date: 3/25/2014 Posts: 928 Location: That's Classified Info Minecraft: WhiteleafYT Xbox: OutboardToaster PSN: Nada Member Details

I, on the other hand agree with this.

Players seem perfectly fine with literally just about any other type of farm, what makes flowers an exception?

Did I ever say I wasn”t okay with farms? No. No support because all of this can already be done, and no other farms duplicate items like this does. No one can convince me to support this as it is useless in my opinion.

My Channel: Whiteleaf

I am an artist. All the art you see on my profile is by me, if it”s not I will say so and whom its owner is.

Newbie Join Date: 12/21/2014 Posts: 4,035 Location: In your hair Minecraft: My_Unit Member Details

Did I ever say I wasn”t okay with farms? No. No support because all of this can already be done, and no other farms duplicate items like this does. No one can convince me to support this as it is useless in my opinion.

Void Walker Location: Minecraft Join Date: 1/19/2014 Posts: 1,659 Location: Earth Minecraft: The_8_Bit_Zombie Member Details

No offense, but that”s not a valid argument. You can duplicate sunflowers, peonies, lilacs, and rose bushes with bonemeal in Minecraft already.

Mark of the Beast Join Date: 3/25/2014 Posts: 928 Location: That's Classified Info Minecraft: WhiteleafYT Xbox: OutboardToaster PSN: Nada Member Details

No offense, but that”s not a valid argument. You can already (as of 1.8) duplicate sunflowers, peonies, lilacs, and rose bushes with bonemeal. So it is the way physics work in MC.
Duplicating defeats the purpose with anything in MC, or outside of it. I don”t care for the tall flowers, as that”s a feature Mojang wanted. If they wanted duplication on small flowers, they”ll add it in. What if diamonds were duplicate-able without any glitches/mods? That totally defeats the purpose of them. They become so common it has no more value. Same with flowers. Sit there for 30 minutes, go fill a chest with all the same types of flowers, repeat. What ever happened to farming in MC, making a nice house, now it”s all about the farms and cheap ways to get things? Villagers, dungeons, the End, the Nether…all these things blocked the view of the old way people used to do things. “Oh I need flowers? Let me just go over to my 16x16x6 storage room and grab a few stacks.”


Dungeons: Do I even have to say?
The end: Endermen farms. Enderman hunting is completely USELESS after you”ve completed the End. Why? Because of Endermen farms. No more going and hunting out in the open desert, plains, etc…just a farm. That was no way to be intended in the game. Now they are common as stone.
Villagers: again, do I even have to say anything? Especially mixed with the Zombie Pigman farms in the Nether, villagers give you emeralds…for rotten flesh? I understand it”s a priest and what not, but I mean that just it pretty cheap. No more hunting for emeralds under huge mountains–heck, was I the only one who ever actually EXPLORED for ores? You can also buy diamond tools from smithes; once you have the people trapped up in cages, you never have to go mining again.
what I”m trying to say, is that Minecraft has become so un natural over time. I remember when it used to be about exploring, hunting, and just plain old fun. Item duplication doesn”t help with this issue, either. I refuse to play MC in these ways if possible, but if it comes to it I will do so.
Keep your suggestion, and I”m not to trying to hate, but I think you should have when you right click it destroys the flowers and gives you 1-2 seeds to plant flowers from, yielding more flowers but not being over powered and cheap.


No more for me, it”s pointless to argue about something I don”t support. and I don”t want to force you into changing it.
Still no support, nor will i ever have any for this suggestion.
Rollback Post to Revision RollBack
My Channel: Whiteleaf

I am an artist. All the art you see on my profile is by me, if it”s not I will say so and whom its owner is.
#17 Apr 30, 2015
megabyte12345
megabyte12345 View User Profile View Posts Send Message
Lapis Lazuli Collector Join Date: 3/28/2015 Posts: 1,081 Minecraft: mistermegabyte Member Details

I like this, it can make it easier if you”re trying to farm 1 specific flower as opposed to continuously spamming bonemeal until you get the flower you want.

Read more: How To Grab Everything In A Chest In Minecraft ? Loot All From Chest

Support; can make it easier to farm flowers.

Leave a Comment